Case Summaries

Our investigative partners are currently working cases that involve missing persons and homicide victims—many of whom are considered cold cases. Below are summaries of a few of the cases we’ve worked on recently or are currently working on.

From the age of 14, Sienna suffered unimaginable sexual abuse at the hands of her parents. But it didn’t end there—her parents trafficked her for money. Eventually, she escaped but ended up on the streets under the control of several prostitution ring leaders. In March of 2021, Sienna disappeared completely. NILJ was asked to find her in November of 2023. Through boots on the ground investigation and interviews, she was found alive in a women’s shelter in January of 2024.

Sienna Doe - Missing Woman Found Alive

Serial Killer Case Victims Uncovered

Mark and team are currently working on uncovering additional victims of a notorious serial killer who is behind bars. Currently, we are working five separate but related homicide cold cases in Suffolk County and Long Island, New York. Three additional cases are being investigated in Manhattan & Queens, NY.

2005 Cold Case - Long Awaited Answers in Missing Teen Case

A teen went missing without a trace in 2005. Local law enforcement and the FBI welcomed NILJ’s assistance in moving the case along after leads dried up years ago. After thorough investigative work and interviews, the NILJ investigative team found the location where the teen’s body was likely hidden. Our valued partner, Stapleton Security Search and Rescue Canine, provided a cadaver dog to work the suspected crime scene. DNA testing is currently underway to validate that the missing teen was murdered in 2005.

Tammy Mahoney: Missing since 1981

Tammy Mahoney's disappearance on May 8, 1981 from upstate New York has haunted investigators and her loved ones for decades. She was 19 when she went missing. Please see the image below for more detail. If you know something about Tammy’s disappearance, call us at 1-833-FINDME or write to us at info@nilj.org.

In the news